Friday, June 15, 2012

A Tale of Two Plans

India is moving toward finalising its Twelfth Five-Year Plan, for 2012-17. The process is long and fascinating. A 140-page draft approach paper was made available late last year, and has been followed by an exceptional process of consultation and discussion, including meetings across the country, a website that allows citizen discussions of specific points and issues, and even a Facebook page. The Plan document, and the framework of 12 strategy challenges, are encompassing in nature, as befits the ambitious goal of faster, sustainable and more inclusive growth.

The world’s other emerging giant, China, also still has Five-Year Plans. In this case, it is only a year or two ahead of India—its Twelfth Plan was finalised last year, and covers the period 2011-15. One cannot imagine the Chinese government having online discussions by citizens for shaping such a document, and certainly not a Facebook page. But more than the process, which is ultimately mostly top-down at the formulation stage for both countries (because that is where the expertise and knowledge mostly reside), the tenor and goals of the two Plans are quite different.

More....

No comments:

Post a Comment